Imagine you’ve built a successful regional chicken-finger restaurant. You have a loyal following and a place in your community. Then Raising Cane’s announces it’s coming to town. Now what?

You can’t outspend them. You can’t out-advertise them. And you’re certainly not going to beat them by becoming a smaller version of Raising Cane’s. But that’s exactly the mistake I’ve watched restaurant companies make throughout my career.

Learn From Competitors Without Becoming Them

During my more than twenty years at Panera, including my time as Chief Concept Officer, I watched countless smaller restaurant companies studying what we were doing, often trying to become their own version of Panera. I understood why. We had built a successful model, and naturally other operators wanted to understand what made it work.

Years later, when I joined Noodles & Company, I saw the other side of that equation. I walked into my office and found stacks of competitive research about Panera. Detailed studies of the menu, strategy, operating model, even a version of the famous No-No List. It was a fascinating reminder of how much time and energy restaurant companies spend studying one another.

And there’s nothing wrong with that. Competitive intelligence is important. But there’s a difference between learning from a competitor and allowing that competitor to define who you become.

The danger isn’t studying the competition. It’s spending so much time looking at what makes them successful that you stop investing in what makes you special.

Put Your Differentiation Through Three Tests

Let’s return to our regional chicken-finger operator. Raising Cane’s is opening three restaurants in your market. That’s a legitimate business threat. They’re bringing national brand recognition, substantial marketing resources, sophisticated operating systems, and a proven concept. You should take that seriously.

But before you start changing your menu, pricing, or marketing to look more like theirs, I’d ask one question: Why were customers choosing you before Cane’s showed up? Was it your food, your sauces, your people, your connection to the community?

But here’s where I’d be careful. What you believe makes your restaurant special and what your customers actually value aren’t always the same thing. Maybe you think it’s your food, but customers really come for convenience. Maybe you’re proud of your service, but the guest experience isn’t as consistent as you believe.

Before deciding what to protect, you need to understand what actually drives customer choice. That means getting into the restaurants, listening to customers, examining the business, and separating genuine competitive advantages from assumptions.

I’d put each potential point of differentiation through three tests:

  1. Guest value: Is this something guests genuinely value—and a reason they choose us?
  2. Consistent execution: Can our operators and teams deliver it consistently?
  3. Profitable economic returns: Does it create profitable economic returns at a cost our business can support?

Differentiation only becomes a sustainable competitive advantage when it passes all three. The objective isn’t to preserve everything that makes you different. It’s to identify what makes you worth choosing, and build a business capable of delivering it profitably.

Make What’s Special Easier to Execute

As restaurant companies grow, they need better systems, stronger training, more consistent execution, and operations that can scale. But somewhere along the way, many operators begin confusing standardization with sameness.

I saw this firsthand developing CoreLife Eatery. We wanted guests to experience food that felt genuinely freshly prepared. One example was carving steak in front of the customer.

Operationally, it would have been easier to use pre-cut, pre-portioned protein. But that would have eliminated something important about the experience. Instead, we engineered the production process around preserving it, using a combi oven to prepare a consistent roast that could be carved to order.

We simplified the work behind the scenes without eliminating what mattered to the guest. The goal wasn’t to make the restaurant easier to operate at any cost. It was to make what was special about the restaurant easier to execute.

Sometimes the very things that make a smaller restaurant company different are the first things its leadership begins eliminating as it prepares to grow. They look at labor, food costs, and complexity. One decision at a time, they start taking things away.

Each decision seems rational. But five years later, they may have a much more efficient restaurant that nobody gets particularly excited about.

That’s not scaling a concept. That’s scaling away your competitive advantage.

Build a Community Around the Brand

At CoreLife Eatery, local-store marketing was an extension of our concept strategy. We deliberately built relationships with yoga studios, gyms, SoulCycle, and other fitness communities whose lifestyles aligned with what our brand stood for.

And we made those relationships visible. We hosted yoga events on CoreLife properties, participated in local runs and sporting activities, and created opportunities for people to experience the brand beyond simply coming in for a meal.

There’s more to local-store marketing than supporting school programs or putting your logo on a Little League jersey. Those are worthwhile activities, but the bigger opportunity is to connect with communities that naturally share your brand’s values.

At CoreLife, we weren’t just marketing in the community. We were building a community around the brand.

That’s a competitive advantage that doesn’t necessarily require a national advertising budget. It requires knowing who your customers are, what matters to them, and where your brand fits into their lives.

Play a Different Game

There’s a quote attributed to Jerry Garcia that I’ve used in speeches for more than a dozen years: “The trick isn’t beating the competition. The trick is not having any.”

I’ve always loved that idea, particularly in the restaurant business. Of course, you’re going to have competitors. Some will be bigger, better funded, and capable of doing things you can’t.

But the objective isn’t to eliminate competition. It’s to build something so distinctive and valuable to your customers that the competition becomes less relevant. That’s what the best restaurant concepts do.

So when Raising Cane’s comes to town, don’t ask how to become more like Raising Cane’s. Ask what you can do that they can’t easily replicate.

Because the strongest competitive position isn’t necessarily being better at someone else’s game. It’s building a business that’s playing a different game altogether.


Scott Davis
Restaurant Growth, Concept & Menu Strategy Consultant
Fractional Chief Concept Officer
scottdaviscco.com